District of Columbia, et. al. v. Heller: One for the Ages
June 27, 2008Attorney Ethics, Choosing a Lawyer, Lawsuits, Miscellaneous, Most Popular Posts, NY Courts, NY Laws and Cases3 CommentsCalling all Constitutional Law Junkies: June 26, 2008 was a monumental day.
It is not often (yet more frequent these days than is perhaps appropriate) that the U.S. Supreme Court authors a decision in which it offers — in nearly 150 pages of disparate, arguably subjective detail — overtly telepathic insight into the minds and hearts of the framers cast under a thin, unimpressive veil of stare decisis. A day to celebrate? Perhaps, as it was for the N.R.A. supporters and the libertarian crowd who view the District of Columbia, et. al. v. Heller through a narrow pragmatic lense as a promotion of individual liberties (and security that they can keep their guns.) A day for outrage? Apparently for a “frightened” Mayor Daley, as he trumpeted the call to fight for the right to ban guns in his hometown and plans were made to challenge similar laws in megapolises across the country.
I felt something in between. I feel scholastic excitement, to be sure. Heller , like Bush v. Gore, will certainly endure as a landmark case in Constitutional Law 101 for centuries to come. The majority opinion, authored by Justice Antonin Scalia and joined by Justices Roberts, Thomas, Alito and Kennedy, is bursting with interesting (if somewhat trivial given Scalia’s general predisposition against extra-four corners constitutional analysis) historical references — James Madison’s inclusion of a conscientious-objector clause in his original draft of the Second Amendment; E. de Vattel’s 1792 “The Law of Nations, or, Principals of the Law of Nature”; England’s 1671 “Game Act”; and, of course, the mighty and ever-persuasive Federalist Papers. (As a reverent admirer of the Papers, Read the rest…


.jpg)

provoked a great deal of response, both on and off this blog. I received a number of e-mails from individuals looking for more information. One person who responded to the blog was Dr. Julia Hallisy, an expert in the area of hospital acquired infections. Dr. Hallisy practices in California, and had her own very personal experience with hospital acquired infections. That story is too personal for me to attempt to summarize, but interested readers can learn more at Dr. Hallisy’s website 
















